German learning woes

from 2010...

Oh dear. Complaining again. Please, teachers/textbook writers, these do NOT help me, and probably few others: guessing games (where one gets far too accustomed to wrong answers); gross overgeneralizations (like I just saw a respected textbook say that a verb is "always" in 2nd place -- of course it isn't, and thankfully I saw a good explanation in April Wilson's German grammar); words completely out of context.

What REALLY works for me, and makes me learn very quickly and happily: CAREFULLY CHOSEN words with CONTEXT via lots of reading PRACTICE, building and building on itself. (Surely spoken language would work similarly.) It makes me feel like I'm really learning something and am not in a whirlwind of unknown words. Yeah, I know you know your language, you don't have to show off; you have to allow me to read at least almost every word. I really don't mind if I have a vocabulary list of 150 words per lesson to do that; I want to read something real-ish at least, and read it well. (I need a compromise between the "This is a pencil; this is a green pencil; this is a red pencil" and the "Gobbledy gook Gobbledy gook Gobbledy gook Theonewordyou'vetaughtsofar Gobbledy gook" approaches.) It also really helps if it's laid out/DESIGNED well; I can barely see a couple cheaper German dictionaries I bought ages ago, and not much better my big one; and a book I've tried to use runs all its sentences and columns together in a weird way and it's difficult to see which goes with what -- don't tell me that a language that had such beautiful script decades ago has forgotten design, Germany is known for attractive and practical design. My French textbook does this stuff like PERFECTLY. Wish the same guy's German textbook didn't cost a gazillion dollars/euros because it's out of print and many others agree with me that he's fabulous. I'm beginning to wonder if I need a teacher's edition of some college textbook in order to teach myself.


(A lot of my woes were solved when I finally just went to Germany and found some fabulous learning sources...)